Coshocton fifth-graders convict the Grinch

There was a new legal battle in town, and it happened in fifth grade at Coshocton Elementary School. Twenty student attorneys, witnesses, judges and jurors recently transformed the classroom into a full courtroom during a mock trial featuring none other than The Grinch.

Students were divided into teams for the prosecution and the defense while others took on the roles of judge and bailiff. After reviewing the evidence, students decided to indict Mr. Grinch on two charges: burglary and theft.

The students prepared for the day by writing their own questions and developing witness responses, but there was one major twist: During cross-examination the witnesses had no idea what questions were coming. Students had to think quickly and stay on their toes throughout the trial.

To make the experience more authentic, jury subpoenas were sent to respected community members including Judge Batchelor, Chrishana Carroll, Mark Mills, Dr. Claxon and Mr. Meiser.

After all testimony and evidence had been presented, the jury left the courtroom to deliberate. Before sending them off, the judge reminded jurors to focus only on the facts presented in the case. Fifteen minutes later the jury returned with a verdict: guilty on both counts.

The Grinch was immediately remanded into custody until his sentencing hearing. Rumor has it the Whos of Whoville are sleeping a little easier now.

When asked about her experience, student judge Chloe Mason said, “At first I was very nervous, but once we started practicing, it became a lot of fun.”

Prosecuting Attorney Jameson Tarman encouraged future students to participate in mock trials.

Mayor Augustus MayWho, played by Jayvan Deran, said his favorite part was interacting with students from other classes. “I enjoyed the cross-examination the best because you had to be on your toes,” he said.

Ms. Kulczycki said she's proud of the students’ hard work and explained this type of learning is called project-based learning.

Throughout the project students practiced writing, public speaking, teamwork and critical thinking skills.