Tappan Lake lessee says obstructed view reveals gaps in property protections

Dear Editor,

We've been lessees at Tappan Lake for nine years, drawn by the lake view that made our home a peaceful retreat—until now.

On July 1, I came home and was devastated. A neighbor, who only visits occasionally from Las Vegas, had constructed an 8.5-by-28-foot cinder block carport that completely blocks our view of the lake. Overnight, our lake view property became just another house on the street.

When I contacted the Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District, I expected concern. Instead, I was asked if I was looking for another home and advised that I could apply for a permit to build a higher deck—at my own expense. There was no mention of my now-decreased property value.

Our lease clearly states that MWCD rules and restrictions exist to “protect the lessee’s investment.” Mine was not protected. I raised the issue with the MWCD Board of Directors and received the same response: if I want my view back, I can pay to build around the problem.

We never planned to alter our home—we purchased it specifically for the view. How can changes this drastic be approved with no regard for their impact on neighboring properties?

There are more than 1,200 MWCD leaseholders. If this can happen to me, it can happen to anyone. Potential buyers should be warned: if your view and your home's value aren’t protected, what exactly are you paying for?

My sanctuary was taken from me. I hope this letter starts a conversation—before someone else loses theirs too.

Sincerely, 

Lori Fluharty 

Scio